earnify is the BP loyalty app that covers BP, Amoco, and ampm fueling stations in the US, with instant 5¢ per gallon off, 1 point per dollar on fuel, 2 points per dollar on convenience purchases, and a 250-point welcome offer for new users. The friction shows up in coverage and posting delays. Outside the participating BP, Amoco, and ampm network, earnify doesn’t earn at all, so drivers in markets without nearby BP stations get no value from the program. Points can take up to 24 hours to post, which makes redemption timing tricky. Point math complexity (1 point per $ fuel vs 2 per $ in-store, redemption thresholds for varying gas discounts) frustrates drivers who just want simple savings. These earnify alternatives target the same gas savings and convenience cashback through different brand loyalty programs or station-agnostic cashback apps.
We picked seven, mixing the two station-agnostic cashback leaders, the major branded gas loyalty apps, and one convenience store app that doubles as a fuel rewards program.
Quick comparison
| App | Best for | Coverage | Earn model |
|---|---|---|---|
| GasBuddy | Cheapest gas near you | Every US station | Per-gallon discount card |
| Upside | Cashback on any station | 70,000+ US stations | Pre-claim per-gallon offer |
| Shell Motorist | Direct Shell savings | Shell US stations | Per-gallon discount |
| ExxonMobil Speedpass+ | Exxon and Mobil rewards | Exxon and Mobil stations | Per-gallon points |
| 7-Eleven | 7Rewards and Speedway crossover | 7-Eleven and Speedway | Points per gallon and item |
| Speedway | Speedy Rewards loyalty | Speedway and 7-Eleven | Points per gallon and item |
| Marathon ARCO ampm | MakeItCount rewards | Marathon, ARCO, ampm | Per-gallon and convenience |
Why people leave earnify
Coverage is BP-network only. BP, Amoco, and ampm stations cover most major US metros but thin out in rural areas, small towns, and large parts of the Northeast outside cities. Drivers who can’t routinely fuel at a BP station earn zero.
Point posting takes up to 24 hours. The lag between fueling and seeing the points hit makes redemption timing tricky, especially if the next fuel-up is the same day or next morning.
Point math is complex. 1 point per $ on fuel, 2 per $ on convenience, with redemption thresholds that vary by gas discount tier and bonus deal. Casual users don’t track the math closely enough to optimize.
The bp rewards Visa promotion is the headline savings. The 30¢ per gallon for 60 days (then 15¢ per gallon) headline requires a Visa card application and credit pull, which most casual drivers won’t do for the gas savings alone.
Receipts and payment integration are imperfect. Some drivers report missing point credit from in-store purchases when the receipt linking fails, and the support flow to fix it takes multiple chat sessions.
Which earnify alternative should you pick
- GasBuddy for the cheapest gas across every nearby station regardless of brand.
- Upside for pre-claim per-gallon cashback that works at most US stations.
- Shell Motorist for direct Shell savings at Shell-branded stations.
- ExxonMobil Speedpass+ for Exxon and Mobil rewards.
- 7-Eleven for 7Rewards and Speedway dual-earn.
- Speedway for Speedy Rewards loyalty.
- Marathon ARCO ampm for MakeItCount across Marathon and ARCO.
Stay on earnify when you regularly fuel at BP, Amoco, or ampm stations, when you have the bp rewards Visa card, and when the in-store rewards at ampm convenience stores actually fit your buying pattern.
1. GasBuddy, cheapest gas near you
GasBuddy crowdsources gas prices at every US station and ranks the cheapest within driving distance. The Pay with GasBuddy card adds a fixed per-gallon discount (currently up to 25¢ for premium members) on top of the lowest already-published price. Station-agnostic coverage means drivers in any market can save without committing to one brand.
earnify vs GasBuddy: earnify locks you into BP network. GasBuddy works at any station. earnify’s BP brand discount can beat GasBuddy on BP stations alone; GasBuddy wins everywhere else.
Where it falls short: the crowdsourced prices occasionally lag the actual pump price by 30-60 minutes. Premium membership at $4.99/month adds expense before you’ve saved.
Pricing: free app. GasBuddy Premium at $4.99 per month adds higher per-gallon discount and theft protection.
Switching from earnify: install GasBuddy, link the Pay with GasBuddy card to your bank account, and use it as the default fuel payment regardless of station brand.
Bottom line: the right call for drivers who don’t have BP coverage and want station-agnostic savings.
2. Upside, pre-claim per-gallon cashback
Upside offers per-gallon cashback that you claim before fueling at participating stations. The offer rate varies by station and time of day, sometimes hitting 25-40¢ per gallon. After fueling, you upload the receipt to claim the cashback, which posts as Upside credit redeemable to PayPal, bank transfer, or gift cards. Upside also covers grocery and restaurant cashback.
earnify vs Upside: earnify offers fixed per-gallon savings tied to BP loyalty. Upside offers variable per-gallon cashback at most US stations. Upside often beats earnify on absolute cashback at non-BP stations.
Where it falls short: receipt upload friction. Cashback amounts vary, sometimes lower than published rates at specific stations. Withdrawals through PayPal carry no fee but bank transfers can have a minimum.
Pricing: free app, no membership.
Switching from earnify: install Upside, claim the cashback offer for your most-used station before fueling, and upload the receipt within the time window after.
Bottom line: the right call for variable cashback at most US gas stations and groceries.
3. Shell Motorist, direct Shell savings
Shell Motorist is Shell’s loyalty app, with per-gallon savings at Shell-branded stations, Fuel Rewards membership integration, and Shell Pay & Save mobile payment at the pump. The Fuel Rewards Gold tier ($50 in eligible purchases over 90 days) keeps the 5¢ per gallon savings active continuously.
earnify vs Shell Motorist: earnify locks to BP network. Shell Motorist locks to Shell network. Drivers in markets where Shell is denser than BP get better coverage with Shell Motorist.
Where it falls short: the Fuel Rewards mechanic is similar in complexity to earnify’s. Outside Shell stations, the app offers nothing.
Pricing: free app. 5¢ per gallon baseline at Fuel Rewards Gold.
Switching from earnify: install Shell Motorist if Shell stations are denser than BP in your market. Sign up for Fuel Rewards Gold and use Shell Pay & Save for in-app pump activation.
Bottom line: the right call when Shell is your closest station network.
4. ExxonMobil Speedpass+, Exxon and Mobil rewards
ExxonMobil Speedpass+ combines mobile payment with the Exxon Mobil Rewards+ loyalty program at over 12,000 Exxon and Mobil stations in the US. Members earn 3 points per gallon on Plus and Supreme grades, 2 per gallon on regular, and 20 points per dollar on store purchases. 100 points convert to 1¢ off per gallon at redemption.
earnify vs ExxonMobil Speedpass+: similar branded-loyalty model. Exxon and Mobil stations are denser than BP in most Northeast and Midwest markets. earnify wins where BP has coverage and ampm convenience purchases are part of the routine.
Where it falls short: point math is fiddly. Speedpass+ payment can fail intermittently at older pump readers.
Pricing: free app. Earn rate varies by grade and product.
Switching from earnify: install Speedpass+ if Exxon and Mobil are your closest stations. Link a payment method and use Speedpass+ at the pump for the loyalty earn.
Bottom line: the right call when Exxon or Mobil is your closest station network.
5. 7-Eleven, 7Rewards and Speedway dual-earn
7-Eleven runs 7Rewards, the convenience-store loyalty program integrated with Speedway’s Speedy Rewards after the Speedway acquisition. Points earn on store purchases, fuel at Speedway stations, and exclusive app deals. Redemptions cover free coffee, Slurpees, sandwiches, and gas discounts.
earnify vs 7-Eleven: earnify focuses on fuel; 7-Eleven leans toward convenience-store rewards with fuel as a secondary earn. 7-Eleven wins for drivers who routinely buy convenience items along with gas.
Where it falls short: the fuel earn rate is lower than dedicated fuel-loyalty programs. Speedway integration has had bugs since the merger.
Pricing: free app.
Switching from earnify: install 7-Eleven if your routine includes 7-Eleven and Speedway stops. The bonus deals on snacks and drinks add up faster than fuel-only programs for high-frequency convenience-store buyers.
Bottom line: the right call for drivers who stop at 7-Eleven or Speedway for more than fuel.
6. Speedway, Speedy Rewards loyalty
Speedway runs Speedy Rewards directly with 10 points per gallon, 20 points per dollar on in-store purchases, and redemption thresholds that produce gas discounts, gift cards, or free items. Speedway stations cluster in the Midwest, Florida, and Ohio Valley. The 7-Eleven acquisition unified the two loyalty programs in 2024.
earnify vs Speedway: similar branded-loyalty model. Speedway has stronger Midwest and Ohio Valley density than BP. earnify wins for drivers who pass BP stations on a daily commute.
Where it falls short: Speedway’s footprint outside its core regions is thin. The post-merger 7Rewards integration has had stability issues.
Pricing: free app.
Switching from earnify: install Speedway if you live in the Midwest, Ohio, or Florida. The Speedy Rewards earn rate is competitive with earnify’s BP loyalty.
Bottom line: the right call for Midwest and Ohio Valley drivers.
7. Marathon ARCO ampm, MakeItCount rewards
Marathon ARCO ampm runs the MakeItCount Rewards program across Marathon, ARCO, and ampm convenience stores. Earn rates are 5¢ per gallon off baseline plus tiered bonuses, with redemption against gas discounts or in-store credit. ARCO’s West Coast density and Marathon’s Midwest footprint make the combined network broad in some markets.
earnify vs Marathon: earnify includes ampm under the BP umbrella. Marathon ARCO ampm runs a different version of ampm in some markets (the BP-owned ampm transitioned earlier; legacy Marathon-owned ampm runs on MakeItCount). Drivers who use ampm convenience stores should check which program applies.
Where it falls short: brand confusion between BP-owned and Marathon-owned ampm in different markets. App-side rewards mechanic is less polished than the major brands.
Pricing: free app.
Switching from earnify: install MakeItCount if your local ampm or ARCO runs under Marathon. The program also covers Marathon-branded stations in the Midwest.
Bottom line: the right call when Marathon-owned ARCO or ampm runs in your market.
How to pick the right earnify alternative
Pick GasBuddy or Upside when station-brand flexibility matters more than loyalty earn. Pick Shell Motorist, ExxonMobil Speedpass+, Speedway, or Marathon when one brand dominates your routine. Pick 7-Eleven when convenience-store purchases drive most of the earn. Stack two apps: a station-agnostic cashback (Upside) plus the branded loyalty of your most-used network.
The pragmatic move: install Upside for cashback regardless of station, and add one branded loyalty for the station you fuel at most often. The combination consistently beats single-program loyalty optimization.
Common questions
Is earnify or GasBuddy cheaper for gas? GasBuddy almost always finds a cheaper pump price than what earnify discounts at a BP station, simply by showing every nearby station’s price. earnify wins on the absolute savings at a specific BP station you’d visit anyway.
Which earnify alternative covers the most stations? Upside has the broadest US station coverage (70,000+ participating sites). GasBuddy indexes every US station for price comparison but only the Pay with GasBuddy card discounts at participating partners.
Can I stack GasBuddy or Upside with earnify? Generally yes. The branded BP loyalty in earnify and the Upside per-gallon cashback can both apply on the same fill-up if the station participates in both programs. Check the offer terms before fueling.
What is the cheapest earnify alternative for premium fuel? ExxonMobil Speedpass+ offers higher point earnings (3 per gallon) on Plus and Supreme grades than the regular fuel earn. Drivers who fill premium routinely earn faster on Exxon and Mobil than on BP through earnify.
